Fall in the Catskills: Color, Markets, and Small Towns

Fall in the Catskills lasts longer than most visitors expect. Color appears on the highest summits by mid-September, moves down the mountainsides through early October, and reaches the valleys and villages later in the month, so a trip can land almost anywhere in a five- or six-week window and still find good color.
The season is about more than the leaves, too. The farmers markets are into their last weeks of fresh produce, the small towns settle into a slower pace, and the trails are finally cool enough to climb in comfort.
How the color moves
The Catskill Park covers roughly 700,000 acres, and its highest peak, Slide Mountain, reaches 4,180 feet. Color follows elevation. The highest summits are covered in dark spruce and fir, so the season’s first color shows among the yellow birch scattered through them. The sugar maple, beech, and birch forests on the mid-elevation slopes follow, and the oak and red maple forests of the lower valleys turn last.
If your trip falls early in the season, drive up to find the color; if it falls late, stay low and walk the valleys. New York State publishes a foliage report every week through the fall, which shows which parts of the region are at their best on a given weekend.
Three drives worth the time
Route 28, the Catskill Mountains Scenic Byway, follows the Esopus Creek through Phoenicia, Big Indian, and Pine Hill, with the mountains rising close on both sides of the road.
Route 23A through Kaaterskill Clove, between Palenville and Haines Falls, is one of the most photographed fall drives in New York, a steep, winding climb with cliffs overhead.
Route 42 north of Shandaken takes a quieter line through Deep Notch, a narrow pass between steep, forested slopes on the way to West Kill.
On foot
Kaaterskill Falls drops about 260 feet in two tiers, and the viewing platform above it is an easy walk of about 0.6 miles round trip from the Laurel House Road parking area, well away from the steep lower trail. Near Big Indian, Giant Ledge climbs roughly 1,000 feet in a little over a mile and a half to a string of open ledges looking east over the Slide Mountain Wilderness.
The five restored fire towers in the Catskill Park, on Hunter, Overlook, Tremper, Balsam Lake, and Red Hill, each give a full-circle view to anyone willing to make the hike and climb the stairs. At North-South Lake, easy trails lead to Artist’s Rock and Sunset Rock, two escarpment viewpoints high above the Hudson Valley, and in Windham the Windham Path makes an easy 1.5-mile loop beside the Batavia Kill.

Farmers markets and the last of the season
Fall is the end of the growing season in the mountains, and the farmers markets are the best place to see it. The Windham Farmers Market runs on Saturdays from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. on Main Street through October 31. The Phoenicia Farmers Market runs on Sundays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. at Parish Field through October, then moves indoors to Pine Hill for the winter.
October is the last month of the outdoor markets and of the season’s fresh produce from local growers, so a fall weekend is the time to stock up. Hunter Mountain holds its Oktoberfest on fall weekends and runs its Scenic Skyride to the summit, an eleven-minute ride with views that reach the Berkshires and Vermont’s Green Mountains.
Small towns worth the drive
The best fall days end in a small town. To the west, Roxbury, Stamford, and Delhi have the kind of main streets the Western Catskills are known for, each with an independent bookstore, a good coffee shop, boutique local shops, and a restaurant worth staying for dinner. To the southeast, Woodstock has the liveliest of these small-town scenes, with bookshops, galleries, and cafes on and around Tinker Street.
Closer to the properties, Tannersville calls itself the Painted Village in the Sky for its brightly colored storefronts. Stop at Shandaken Bake on Main Street for seasonal pastries, browse the thrift stores, and check what is on at the Orpheum Performing Arts Center, which shows films and hosts music, theater, and dance. Just outside the village, the Mountain Top Arboretum spreads across 200 acres at 2,400 feet, open every day and free to visit.
Windham has a bookshop, small restaurants that stay busy through the season, and Gardenheir, a modern garden store. For a slower afternoon, Windham Spa, minutes from the property, has a spa with massage, facials, and wellness boutique.
Phoenicia, on Route 28, is the quietest of the group: a small hamlet with a well-known diner and an old-fashioned, thrift-shop charm.
Where to stay
Eastwind has two properties in these mountains, and each suits a different kind of fall trip.
Eastwind Windham is the more sociable of the two, with 23 rooms and 10 cabins within walking distance to town and close to Kaaterskill Clove and the festival weekends. It has a restaurant and bar on site; the Windham amenities page has the full list, and Eastwind’s Catskills guide maps the trails and restaurants nearby.
Eastwind Oliverea Valley is the quieter retreat, set in a narrow hollow just south of Big Indian, with 12 rooms and 14 cabins, Dandelion, its restaurant, an all-season heated pool, and saunas. Its amenities page and area guide cover the rest.

